Compel a Trust Accounting in New York Surrogate’s Court
A Trust accounting provides beneficiaries and interested parties with a detailed overview of the trust’s financial transactions and activities. When there is a lack of transparency or information, you can compel a trust accounting.
To Compel a trust accounting in New York Surrogate’s Court, you must be familiar with SCPA 2205 and SCPA 2206. This blog post outlines the steps and considerations involved in compelling a trust accounting in New York Surrogate’s Court, focusing on SCPA 2205 and SCPA 2206, and includes the procedure for filing a petition to compel a trust accounting.
Understand the Legal Basis and SCPA 2205, SCPA 2206:
Before proceeding, it’s crucial to understand the legal basis for compelling a trust accounting in New York. The New York Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL) and the Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act (SCPA), particularly SCPA 2205 and SCPA 2206, govern trust accounting and the rights of beneficiaries.
Establish Standing To Compel a Trust Accounting:
To compel a trust accounting under SCPA 2205 and SCPA 2206, you need to have legal standing as a concerned party. This typically includes being a beneficiary, an interested party, or someone with a legal interest in the trust. Ensure you have the legal authority to request an accounting.
Review the Trust Document.
Familiarize yourself with the trust document Understanding both the trust’s terms and the relevant statutory provisions is crucial in making a compelling case in Surrogate’s Court. Make sure you are in fact either a beneficiary under the Trust or a person interested in the Trust, a creditor of the Trust, or have the appropriate relationship with the Trust.
Send a Demand Letter and Draft and File a Petition to Compel a Trust Accounting:
Before you actually file a petition to compel a trust accounting, you should send a demand letter to the Trustee, requesting an accounting. This will show the Court that you attempted to amicably resolve matters first before running to Court. It will also show the Court that the trustee is not being responsive.
If the Trustee has not responded to your letter and request for an accounting, then you can prepare a formal petition to compel a trust accounting. The petition should clearly outline the reasons for requesting a trust accounting.
The petition can be fairly basic. It just needs to say who you are, your relationship to the trust, and your attempts to get information from the Trustee. You should also explain to the Court that the Trustee has rebuffed or even ignored your requests.
Ensure that your petition complies with the formatting and content requirements of the New York Surrogate’s Court.
File the Petition with the Surrogate’s Court:
Submit the drafted petition to the Surrogate’s Court in the appropriate county in New York. Pursuant to SCPA 207, the correct venue is either: the County where the Trustee resides, or the County where there is Trust property, or, where the grantor of the trust resided at the time the proceeding was commenced.
You will need to file a Petition and a Citation. Follow the court’s guidelines for filing, including paying any necessary filing fees and ensuring that all required documentation is included.
Serve Notice to All Relevant Parties:
Once the Court reviews your petition, the Court will issue a Citation. You must then serve the Citation on all interested parties, including the trustee and other beneficiaries, as required by law. This ensures that all parties are informed of the proceedings and have an opportunity to respond.
On the return date of Citation, you should appear and explain that you are entitled to an accounting but the Trustee has refused to provide same. The Court will likely Order an Accounting of the Trust.
The Court will ask you to prepare the Order directing the accounting. You will then prepare the Order and after preparing the Order, submit it to the Court. Once the Court signs the Order, you must serve a CERTIFIED COPY of the Order to Account on the Trustee.
The reason you serve as certified copy is so that the clock can start on the Trustees obligation to account. If the Trustee does NOT account after being served with the Certified Copy, then you can move to remove the Trustee or hold the Trustee in contempt of Court.
Review the Trust Accounting:
Once the trust accounting is provided, review it carefully. Typically the Trustee will have to judicially settle the account, which means you will be able to not only review the Trust accounting, but you will also be entitled to the backup of the Trust. You will also be allowed to depose the Trustee in what are known as SCPA 2211 examinations. This can thereafter lead to a contested accounting proceeding.
FAQ’s on Compelling a Trust Accounting In New York
A trust accounting is a detailed report showing how a trustee has managed trust assets. It generally identifies the property received by the trustee, income earned, expenses paid, distributions made to beneficiaries, trustee commissions, and the assets remaining in the trust.
A formal accounting allows beneficiaries and other interested parties to review the trustee’s administration and determine whether trust assets have been properly managed and distributed.
Yes. A person with the necessary interest in a trust may petition the New York Surrogate’s Court to compel the trustee to file an accounting. SCPA 2205 authorizes the court to require a fiduciary to file an intermediate or final account, and SCPA 2206 governs the proceeding after an accounting is compelled.
Whether a particular person has standing depends on that person’s interest in the trust. New York courts have dismissed petitions where the petitioner was not a beneficiary or otherwise a “person interested” within the meaning of the SCPA
A compulsory accounting may be appropriate when a trustee refuses to provide meaningful financial information, has not explained distributions or expenses, has failed to make distributions required by the trust, or when there are concerns about missing assets, excessive trustee commissions, self-dealing, improper transfers, or other possible breaches of fiduciary duty.
An accounting can also be useful even when misconduct has not yet been established. The purpose of the proceeding is often to obtain the information necessary to determine what happened to the trust property.
Not necessarily. A beneficiary seeking an accounting generally does not first have to prove that the trustee misappropriated trust assets. The accounting itself is a mechanism for obtaining a formal explanation of the trustee’s administration.
If the accounting later reveals questionable transactions, a beneficiary may have an opportunity to file objections and seek appropriate relief from the Surrogate’s Court.
Yes. Filing the accounting does not mean that the trustee’s conduct has been approved. An interested party may object to particular transactions or omissions shown—or not shown—in the accounting.
Depending on the circumstances, objections may involve allegations such as improper distributions, failure to collect trust property, unauthorized payments, excessive commissions, conflicts of interest, self-dealing, unexplained withdrawals, or losses caused by a breach of fiduciary duty.
In many circumstances, yes. Disputes concerning lifetime trusts can be heard in Surrogate’s Court, including proceedings seeking to compel an accounting from the trustee after the creator’s death.
New York courts continue to address compulsory accountings involving lifetime and testamentary trusts under SCPA 2205 and 2206
Trust accounting proceedings are frequently brought in the New York Surrogate’s Court having jurisdiction over the trust. Determining the proper county can depend on factors including how the trust arose, the residence of the creator or trustee, prior Surrogate’s Court proceedings, and other jurisdictional circumstances.
The Surrogate’s Court will ordinarily establish a deadline in its order directing the trustee to account. If the trustee does not comply, the petitioner may seek further relief.
Under SCPA 2205 and 2206, continued failure to account can have significant consequences, potentially including suspension or removal of the fiduciary
Although a beneficiary may be able to commence certain proceedings without counsel, trust accounting proceedings can become complicated quickly. Questions may arise concerning standing, jurisdiction, discovery, objections, trustee commissions, fiduciary duties, tracing of assets, damages, and potential removal or surcharge of the trustee.
An attorney experienced in New York trust and estate litigation can evaluate whether a compulsory accounting proceeding is appropriate and what additional relief should be requested.
Conclusion:
In order to Compel a trust accounting in New York Surrogate’s Court involves a thorough understanding of relevant laws, legal standing, and a proper procedure for filing a petition. Seeking professional legal guidance and following the appropriate steps while considering SCPA 2205 and SCPA 2206 will help you navigate the process and uphold transparency and accountability in trust management.
For more information, please contact NYC Probate Litigation, Guardianship, Probate, and Estate Planning attorney Regina Kiperman:
Phone: 917-261-4514
Fax: 929-556-2089
Email: rkiperman@rklawny.com
Or visit her at:
40 Wall Street
Suite 2508
New York, NY 10005
Visit Regina on LinkedIn
Visit Regina on Facebook
This page is made available by the lawyer for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this site you understand that there is no attorney client relationship between you and the lawyer. The post should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state. ATTORNEY ADVERTISING.