How to Compel Production of a Will in NYC
Bob dies. At the time of his death, you find a copy of his Last Will and Testament (“Will”) among his possessions. The Will was drafted by an attorney. You call the attorney who tells you that he is not providing you with any information. Your copy of the Will shows that Bob’s brother, Al, is the nominated executor. You call Al. Al says that there is nothing to probate so he is not going to do a thing. You know Bob had assets but you cannot do anything without that Will. You need to compel production of a Will. How do you do it?
Who may Petition to Compel Production of a Will?
Pursuant to SCPA 1401, the following persons may compel production of a Will:
- any person who receives under the Will, or is a fiduciary, or guardian of a person who receives under the Will.
- a creditor
- any person entitled to letters of Administration, cta.
- the public administrator
- a party to an action to brought or to be brought.
How do you Compel Production of a Will?
The proceeding is commenced with the filing of a Petition, and Order to Attend and be Examined, and the payment of a Filing fee of $20.
The Contents of the Petition:
The Petition should state:
- The relationship of the individual to the Decedent
- The authority of the individual to commence the Petition.
- The information that the individual has to as who has the Will, or, who may have destroyed the Will.
- The attempts that the individual undertook to have the person(s) file the Will with the Court. (Prior to filing the Petition, it may be a good idea to send a letter to the person(s) believed to be in possession of the Will. The letter should ask that the person(s) file the Will with the Court. This letter should set a date by which the Will should be put on file. This letter should then be attached as an Exhibit to the the Petition.)
- All interested parties to the proceeding
- A request that the person(s) in possession of the Will pay attorney fees for the bringing of this petition.
- A request that the person(s) be ordered to file the Will with the Court at the conclusion of any examination which demonstrates they have the Will in their possession.
The Order to Attend
Instead of a Citation, you are preparing an Order to Attend – an Order that sets forth the date that the person believed to be in possession of the Will should appear in Court and be directed to give testimony as to the whereabouts of the Will. You should prepare the proposed Order for the Court to sign.
Where do you file the Petition to Compel?
Go to the Court that has jurisdiction over your decedent. That is, go to the Court in the county where the Decedent died. Submit your Petition, your Order to attend and pay the filing fee. The Court will review the documents to make sure that all is in proper form. If all is in proper form, the Court will then contact you with a signed Order.
You must serve the signed Order, along with the Petition, upon the “respondent” or person that you want to examine. The Order will direct the manner of service. if the person resides in New York, service will be personal service. If the person resides outside of New York, then service may be done by certified mail, return receipt requested. The Order will set forth the deadline by which service must be completed. You should file your affidavit of service that you served the party at least two days before the return date of the Order so that the Court can review its file to make sure that jurisdiction is complete.
What Happens on the Return Date of your Petition to Compel?
Typically, on the return date, the person who was Ordered to appear has to appear and the examination can take place in the Court house after the Calendar call.
If that person indicates, on the record, before the Court reporter, that they are in possession of the Will, then they will be Ordered to place that Will on file with the Court immediately.
We can help you compel the production of a Will. Contact us to learn more.
For more information, please contact probate and estate planning attorney Regina Kiperman:
Or visit her at her new location:
80 Maiden Lane
New York, NY 10038
This post is made available by the lawyer for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this site you understand that there is no attorney client relationship between you and the lawyer. The post should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state. ATTORNEY ADVERTISING.