Pre-Objection Discovery (SCPA § 1404) is essential in Surrogate’s Court
Why Pre-Objection Discovery (SCPA § 1404) matters—especially in Kings County
Before you decide to file objections to probate, New York lets you investigate first. Under SCPA § 1404, an interested party may examine (under oath) the attesting witnesses, the attorney-drafter, and—if the Will has a no-contest clause—the nominated executors and the proponent, along with targeted document discovery. This is your chance to test the will’s validity and decide whether to object.
In Brooklyn practice, smart use of 1404 discovery frequently narrows issues (capacity, due execution, undue influence), positions you for settlement, or builds a clean record for objections.
Who Can Demand Pre-Objection Discovery?
You must have standing—i.e., your interest would be adversely affected if the will is admitted.
Who Has Standing Under SCPA § 1410 to Demand SCPA § 1404 Examinations in Pre-Objection Discovery?
Baseline rule. Standing turns on pecuniary harm:
“Any person whose interest in property or in the estate of the testator would be adversely affected by the admission of the will to probate may file objections …” (and thus may invoke 1404 to investigate before deciding). The statute carves out a narrow exception—someone whose only financial interest is fiduciary commissions generally may not object absent court leave for good cause.
Why this Controls 1404 access. Courts equate the right to take pre-objection discovery with the right to object: if you lack SCPA 1410 standing, you can’t compel 1404 exams. Example: the DVA claimed standing because it might take the estate if there were no valid will; the court held DVA was essentially a creditor and lacked standing—so no 1404.
Categories that usually DO have standing (and may demand 1404):
- Distributees (heirs-at-law) who would take more under intestacy (or a prior instrument) than under the propounded will. Conversely, if a distributee takes more under the will than intestacy, standing fails.
- Beneficiaries of a prior will/codicil whose bequests are reduced or eliminated by the later instrument (including partial-invalidity theories). Appellate decisions recognize standing for a prior-will beneficiary adversely affected by admission of the new will.
- Trustees/remaindermen whose interests are cut off by a power of appointment exercised in the propounded will (they’re “adversely affected,” so they may object and pursue 1404).
- Non-distributee legatees to challenge a portion of the will that adversely affects them (e.g., the executor clause), even if they wouldn’t benefit from total denial of probate—AD2d permitted a legatee to object to the appointment provision.
Who does NOT have standing (and thus cannot force 1404):
- Creditors (including governmental payors positioned as creditors) — no pecuniary improvement from denial of probate.
- Persons whose only interest is commissions as a would-be fiduciary displaced by a later instrument—barred by the 1410 text unless the court grants leave.
- Anyone better off under the propounded will than under intestacy/prior plan—no adverse effect.
Kings County practice pointer. Kings Surrogates will focus first on standing before reaching merits. In a 2025 Brooklyn decision, the court rejected objections as a nullity for lack of SCPA 1410 standing and admitted the instrument; note the GAL had conducted 1404s for an interested party, highlighting that the examiner must have (or act for someone with) standing.
What you Can Examine—and Why it’s Powerful
Under SCPA § 1404(4) you may examine, before or after objections:
- Attesting witnesses (execution formalities, testator demeanor, who was present).
- Attorney-drafter (planning history, prior drafts, checklists, capacity observations).
- If the will contains an in terrorem clause: the nominated executors and the proponent.
These examinations are calibrated to the statutory will formalities in EPTL 3-2.1 (signature, two witnesses, publication, etc.). Tailor your questions and requests to these elements.
Safe Harbor Note (No-Contest Clauses): 1404 exams and certain related proceedings do not trigger forfeiture under a no-contest clause; the safe harbors are codified in EPTL 3-3.5(b) and reaffirmed in recent appellate discussion.
Kings County, Brooklyn—local logistics you should know
- Court & filings: Kings County Surrogate’s Court, 2 Johnson Street, Brooklyn, NY 11201. Regular business hours are generally Mon–Fri, 9:00–5:00.
- E-Filing: Kings Surrogate’s Court requires/encourages NYSCEF e-filing for most proceedings and subsequent documents (including discovery-related filings). Check the Kings Surrogate’s e-filing protocol before you file
Step-by-step: How pre-objection discovery typically runs in Kings County
- Appear At the Return Date of Citation and advise the Court that you want to conduct SCPA 1404 Examinations. The Court will typically have a conference and will set a discovery schedule for conducting the examinations.
- Serve a 1404 Demand + Document Requests. Identify the witnesses and the attorney-drafter; request dates for examinations and a rolling production of files you’ll need to examine intelligently. (Many Brooklyn matters proceed by stipulation and NYSCEF notices.)
- Request the right documents up front. See the checklist below.
- Schedule and conduct the exams. Take the attesting witnesses first, then the attorney-drafter; if there’s a no-contest clause, examine the nominated executor/proponent within the safe harbor.
- Calendar your objections deadline. After 1404s, the Court will set (or confirm) a date by which objections must be filed—don’t miss it. (Courts typically fix a deadline of 10 days upon completion of 1404; some county rules expressly say counsel will be advised of the last day to object.)
- Decide whether to object. Use transcripts + documents to evaluate capacity, undue influence, fraud, duress, mistake, due-execution defects, and revocation. If the record is thin, consider settlement or waivers; if strong, draft focused objections anchored to the proof.
The Brooklyn 1404 Document Checklist (practical and targeted)
Ask for what proves—or disproves—the core theories:
- Attorney-drafter file: intake notes, engagement letter, due-execution checklist, emails, calendars, drafts/redlines, execution-ceremony notes, billing records (time entries often reveal who was present and for how long).
- Prior estate-planning instruments: earlier wills/codicils, trust agreements, and revoked drafts.
- Capacity & vulnerability: primary-care and specialist medical records around execution (with HIPAA authorizations), medication lists, neuro evaluations (if any), home-health aide logs, hospital/rehab charts.
- Influence vectors: correspondence and calendar entries showing who scheduled the appointment, arranged transportation, or paid the bill; routing slips; memo lines on checks; emails/texts by the chief beneficiary.
- Execution ceremony: witness statements, notary logs, office visitor logs/security, video (if any).
- Digital breadcrumbs: email headers, document metadata (creation/modified users/timestamps), DocuSign/scan history (where applicable).
What 1404 testimony should cover
- Due execution (EPTL 3-2.1): Was the will signed in the presence of the witnesses? Did the testator publish the instrument as a will? Were both witnesses present (or acknowledged) and did they sign?
- Capacity: Did the testator understand the nature/extent of assets, the natural objects of bounty, and the plan being executed?
- Undue influence / fraud: Who selected the lawyer? Who gave instructions? Who was in the room? Any “unnatural” provisions or last-minute changes?
- In terrorem dynamics: If a no-contest clause exists, confirm your right to examine the nominated executor and proponent within the statutory safe harbor.
Timing, transcripts, and next steps
- When to start: Demand 1404 discovery promptly after appearance so you have time to examine and—only if warranted—file objections by the Court’s deadline. (Courts set a post-1404 objections date; get it in writing.)
- Transcripts: Order certified transcripts; they frame your objections and preserve testimony for later motion practice or trial.
- If issues arise: Move for protective orders or further relief under CPLR Article 31 where needed (e.g., scope disputes, privilege logs, or additional custodians).
Brooklyn-specific Pre-Objection Discovery FAQs
No. EPTL 3-3.5(b) creates safe harbors; SCPA § 1404 examinations fall within those protections, allowing you to examine without forfeiting a legacy.
Any person with standing—whose interest would be adversely affected by probate—may do so (think: distributees or prior-will beneficiaries). SCPA § 1410.
Attesting witnesses, the attorney-drafter, and—if there’s a no-contest clause—the nominated executors and the proponent. SCPA § 1404(4).
File via NYSCEF and coordinate dates with counsel/the Court; exams are often conducted at counsel’s office, in the courthouse, or remotely by stipulation. (See Kings Surrogate’s e-filing protocol.)
Neighborhood coverage: We regularly handle will-contest matters for families in Park Slope, Brooklyn Heights, Williamsburg, Greenpoint, Crown Heights, Midwood, Bay Ridge, Bensonhurst, Flatbush, Sheepshead Bay, DUMBO, Sunset Park, and beyond.
For more information, please contact NYC Probate Litigation, Guardianship, Probate, and Estate Planning attorney Regina Kiperman:
Phone: 917-261-4514
Fax: 929-556-2089
Email: rkiperman@rklawny.com
Or visit her at:
40 Wall Street
Suite 2508
New York, NY 10005
Visit Regina on LinkedIn
Visit Regina on Facebook
This page is made available by the lawyer for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this site you understand that there is no attorney client relationship between you and the lawyer. The post should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state. ATTORNEY ADVERTISING.