Timing of Filing a Spousal Right of Election in New York

Timing of Filing a Spousal Right of Election in New York

In New York, a surviving spouse cannot usually be completely disinherited. Even if a Will leaves the spouse little or nothing, New York law gives the surviving spouse the right to claim an “elective share” of the estate. This is known as the spousal right of election under EPTL § 5-1.1-A.

However, timing is critical. Many surviving spouses lose valuable rights because the notice of election was filed too late or improperly served. Understanding the filing deadlines, extension procedures, and court discretion is essential when protecting a surviving spouse’s inheritance rights.

What Is the Spousal Right of Election?

Under New York Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (“EPTL”) § 5-1.1-A, unless waived, a surviving spouse is entitled to receive the greater of:

• $50,000; or
• One-third of the decedent’s net estate.

The elective share applies not only to probate assets passing under a Will, but also to many “testamentary substitutes,” including joint accounts, transfer-on-death accounts, retirement accounts, revocable trusts, and certain lifetime transfers. 

For example, if a husband leaves his entire probate estate to his children but also maintained substantial joint investment accounts with another person, the surviving spouse may still assert an elective share claim against those assets.

What Is the Deadline to File a Spousal Right of Election?

The filing deadline is governed by EPTL § 5-1.1-A(d)(1). The statute provides that the election must be made:

• Within six months from the issuance of Letters Testamentary or Letters of Administration; and
• In no event later than two years after the decedent’s death. 

The six-month period begins when the Surrogate’s Court officially appoints the fiduciary and issues letters.

Example of Timing of Filing a Spousal Right of Election

Suppose a decedent dies on January 1, 2024. Letters Testamentary are issued on June 1, 2024. The surviving spouse generally has until December 1, 2024 to file the notice of election.

If no estate proceeding is commenced and no letters are issued, the spouse must still file within two years of death.

What Happens If You Miss the Deadline?

If the surviving spouse fails to timely serve and file the notice of election, the right may be permanently waived. New York courts strictly enforce these deadlines. 

Importantly, merely objecting to a Will or participating in estate litigation does not preserve the elective share claim. A formal written notice of election must be served and filed.

Courts have repeatedly held that compliance with the statutory procedure is required.

How Do You Properly File a Notice of Election?

To properly assert the right of election, the surviving spouse must:

1. Prepare a written Notice of Election;
2. Serve the notice upon the executor, administrator, or nominated executor; and
3. File the original notice with the Surrogate’s Court where the estate proceeding is pending. 

Both service and filing are required. Service alone is not sufficient.

Although notarization is not expressly required by statute, notices are commonly acknowledged before a notary.

Can You File a Late Notice of Election?

Yes. In certain circumstances, the Surrogate’s Court may permit a late filing.

EPTL § 5-1.1-A(d)(2) gives the Surrogate’s Court discretion to extend the time to file the election. The court may grant relief where there is:

• Excusable delay;
• Ongoing estate litigation;
• Delayed discovery of estate assets;
• Fraud or concealment by fiduciaries; or
• Other equitable reasons justifying the extension.

However, extensions are not automatic.

How Do You Request Permission to File Late?

A surviving spouse seeking to file late must petition the Surrogate’s Court for leave to serve and file a late notice of election.

Typically, the application includes:

• A Petition or Order to Show Cause;
• An affidavit explaining the delay;
• Evidence supporting the spouse’s claim;
• A proposed Notice of Election; and
• Proof that interested parties received notice.

The court will consider several factors, including:

• Whether the estate has already been distributed;
• Whether beneficiaries would suffer prejudice;
• Whether the spouse acted promptly upon learning of the issue; and
• Whether the delay was reasonable under the circumstances.

Example of Poor Timing of Filing a Spousal Right of Election

Assume a surviving spouse was unaware that the decedent transferred substantial assets into a revocable trust before death. The executor concealed those assets, and the spouse only learned of them after the statutory deadline expired.

In that situation, the spouse may ask the court to permit a late election based on newly discovered information and equitable considerations.

Cases Addressing Timing of Filing a Spousal Right of Election

New York courts have recognized that the Surrogate’s Court has discretion to permit late filings under appropriate circumstances.

In cases involving delayed asset disclosure or ongoing litigation, courts have sometimes granted extensions where justice required preserving the spouse’s statutory rights.

At the same time, courts routinely deny late applications where the spouse simply ignored the deadline or failed to act diligently.

Because the decision is discretionary, factual details matter greatly.

Why Timing of Filing a Spousal Right of Election Matters in Estate Litigation

The elective share calculation often depends on identifying testamentary substitutes and valuing complex assets. Delays can create significant problems because:

• Assets may already be distributed;
• Beneficiaries may spend estate funds;
• Financial records may disappear; and
• Fiduciaries may argue waiver or estoppel.

For this reason, surviving spouses should consult estate litigation counsel immediately after learning they may have been disinherited or inadequately provided for.

Common Mistakes on Timing of Filing a Spousal Right of Election

Surviving spouses frequently make procedural mistakes that jeopardize their rights.

Common errors include:

• Filing after the statutory deadline;
• Serving the wrong fiduciary;
• Failing to file the notice with the court;
• Assuming probate objections preserve election rights;
• Waiting for asset valuations before filing; and
• Failing to investigate testamentary substitutes.

Even if the estate appears small, substantial non-probate assets may still be subject to the elective share calculation.

Frequently Asked Questions About Timing of Filing a Spousal Right of Election

Final Thoughts on Timing of Filing a Spousal Right of Election

The timing requirements for filing a spousal right of election in New York are strict, but relief may still be available in appropriate cases. Surviving spouses should act quickly to investigate estate assets, preserve claims, and avoid procedural pitfalls.

Where there are hidden assets, delayed probate proceedings, or complex testamentary substitutes, prompt legal action can make the difference between preserving and losing substantial inheritance rights.

---

For more information, please contact NYC Probate Litigation, Guardianship, Probate, and Estate Planning attorney Regina Kiperman:

Phone: 917-261-4514
Fax: 929-556-2089
Email: rkiperman@rklawny.com

Or visit her at:
40 Wall Street
Suite 2508
New York, NY 10005
Visit Regina on LinkedIn
Visit Regina on Facebook

This page is made available by the lawyer for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this site you understand that there is no attorney client relationship between you and the lawyer. The post should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state. ATTORNEY ADVERTISING.